Having grown up with the cult classic “Hocus Pocus” I was excited to get my hands on the written sequel. Though that excitement was short-lived. I will be upfront and honest with my readers, I was not impressed with this book, not even a tad bit, and that saddens me.
Part 1 of the book is the best part of the book by far, yet I can’t say that it is a good part of the sequel because it isn’t. The sequel of the story is in part two. Part 1 simply retells what we saw in the movies with one change. The added character of Elizabeth Sanderson (the fourth sister). As Emily is lured away from home by Sarah Sanderson’s enchanting song, Elizabeth stops her and warns her to not follow the singing, but Emily Binx continues on her way.
Part 2 includes the same cast of characters and their offspring. Max and Allison married, moved away from Salem and later returned, they had a daughter and named her Poppy. The sequel follows Poppy and her friends Travis and Isabella, along with their bully Kate Taylor (the daughter of Jay Taylor who was the plaid wearing bully from the original Hocus Pocus). Poppy is also close to her Aunt Dani who is coming home soon to celebrate Halloween, though the Dennison family isn’t one for Halloween.

Part two opens up with Poppy in school, specifically history class which is taught by her father, Max Dennison. If you ever saw the original, you’re probably questioning this as I did. I could never picture “Hollywood” as a teacher. He scoffed at school, especially history. Students want their teacher to follow suit and discuss the Sandersons like every teacher of the school did 25 years prior, it is a tradition. However, Max’s family doesn’t speak of the Sandersons. Max and Allison told their daughter and her best friend, Travis, about their encounter and the teens never really took them seriously but got the point that it was to never be brought up. Poppy attempts to save her father from having to retell the history of the sisters (no one aside from Max, Dani, and Allison and a couple of others-we’ll get to that later-remember that Halloween 25 years ago due to some spell work from the witches). Poppy’s efforts were squashed when her crush, Isabella Richards, raises her hand and asks if Elizabeth Sanderson was evil like her sisters.
Later that day Isabella asks Poppy and Travis to join her for lunch (which students are allowed to eat off-campus as long as they are back before the tardy bell to the following period). While in a pizza restaurant Poppy tells Isabella her family’s absurd story about the Sandersons. Katie or “Tattle-tale Taylor” as her classmates call her overhears the crazy story. Katie is the daughter of the high school principal, Jay Taylor. The same Jay Taylor bullied Max and Dani. His pal didn’t stick around Salem, after graduation, he left the state to start fresh. Here’s what I don’t get as a reader, there’s no logical connection here. These two guys were headed for drop out status due to truancy and generally not giving a darn about their schooling. How did they jump as 11th or 12th graders (based on age, not actual status-as an educator my mind tells me surely these boys were not on-level) to suddenly having successful careers and one in education? As an educator this also doesn’t track with me, it would take a lot to convince me that these two suddenly cared to do anything worthwhile with their lives.
Allison and Max are hosting a party for all of the students on Halloween, which confuses Poppy and Travis because of her family’s stance against the holiday. The reader soon learns this is their way of keeping an eye on the kids because the spellbook was never recovered. If you’ve seen the original movie you might remember at the end of the film in the credits that the spell book’s eye opens up. Isabella, of course, comes to the party and she has a spirit board & shockingly the spellbook! When asked by Poppy how she came to have possession of the book Isabella claims it just appeared on her bed earlier that day and she suspects it is because she is a descendant of Elizabeth Sanderson (which is why she wanted to know if her ancestor was evil or not). Again this doesn’t track. The book just randomly appear? The book was never able to move on its own before so how did it appear on her bed? This is never explained and as a reader, I don’t trust Isabella’s version of the story but it is never again addressed and throughout the book, she’s a protagonist.

The kids ditched the party to see the old Sanderson home; just like Max, Allison, and Dani all did before. Now I’m starting to see a pattern and the book begins to feel like the same old story again…you’d think this would be comforting but it isn’t I want a sequel to be new, different and exciting! While using the spirit board to connect with who they think might be Elizabeth beyond the veil Poppy is tricked into reciting a spell from the book. There’s enough time for Poppy’s parents and her Aunt Dani to appear before the spell takes over and they disappear in front of them while the “veil” is ripped open and they are replaced by the original trio of witches. In the ensuing fight with the sisters, Isabella is turned into a Boston Terrier…Thackery Binx as a cat all over again. I suppose it isn’t a Disney story unless there’s some talking animal component. They are then chased into the graveyard where they are greeted by Thackery and Emily Binx. Isabella is also introduced to Elizabeth Sanderson’s apparition. She reveals that the spell doesn’t end at sunup like the previous spell did, instead it becomes permanent. The switching spell sent the Dennisons to Hell in place of the wicked sisters. Using Sarah’s voice and the invention of the cell phone they plan to lure the town to them so that they can use the same spell to bring more witches back from Hell. The only way to defeat them is to destroy the family’s magical stone a “blood moonstone” that had been entrusted to Elizabeth while she was alive. Elizabeth believes that their mother knew the other three were up to no good and didn’t want the stone to fall into the hands of evil.
With some local knowledge, the three friends realize that the stone must be buried somewhere near the lighthouse. The keeper of the lighthouse is Principal Taylor. Taylor upon hearing that the Sandersons have returned refuses to help Poppy, Travis, and Isabella (though he doesn’t realize Isabella is the dog with the other two). When Poppy demands to know why he explains that he remembers the first time the sisters paid Salem a visit postmortem. Jay and “Ice” were left hanging in cages in the Sanderson home after being taunted and threatened. That why Jay’s friend, Ernie/”Ice”, left town. They had been traumatized and Jay stuck around Salem to prevent anything like it from happening again. Yet here we go again with a disconnect. If he wants to prevent it or give aid if it ever happened again then this is his moment, yet he refuses to help any Dennison because Max left him and Ernie in the cages that night after taking his shoes back from them.
While all of this happens the wretched sisters are using Isabella’s cell phone (they found after turning her into a dog and the teens running away) and learn that it can connect them to each child with a similar “box” and they can hear Sara’s voice making it easier to entrance them. Here’s yet another disconnect. There’s no need for this at all. In the original movie and they kept true to it in part one, Sarah’s voice reaches every child rather quickly without the aid of a bullhorn, therefore, she could easily do it again and using the phone only makes the process take longer. As they begin to move about the town looking for the family stone they come across a magic shop Sarah and Winifred keep moving and Mary is distracted and begins to sing her song (a musical number then follows where it is only Mary singing about how she’ll be the one to come out on top not Winifred and the stones follow in dance-like movements behind her). Wait, wait, just wait a sec. What the heck is a musical number doing here? Yes, there was a good one in the original with Winifred singing “I Put a Spell on You” but there was a purpose to that, she did put a spell on the adults at that party, turned them into dancing zombies, even when tired they couldn’t stop dancing. This spell kept them occupied so that the children didn’t have anyone to help them rescue the town. The scene with Mary’s musical number in the book just did not fit and as a reader, I felt like that scene was a waste of time.

Eventually Poppy, Isabella, and Travis discover that Katie hasn’t been “zombified” by Sarah’s song to disobey her father who wanted her to be locked in at home with him and drive them to the lighthouse. The stone is found but it is shatterproof of course because that would be all to easy to just smash it with a shovel, it is magical after all. As the witches are able to cast the spell they summon more and more of their coven from Hell while the teens of Salem are sent to Hell in their place. The sisters’ mother is raised from Hell with this spell and it is revealed (to no one’s surprise) that she never intended the stone be kept away from evil just kept away from Winifred because their mother wanted the power for herself. Isabella discovered that she has powers (what great timing to find out you’ve got natural witch powers, no one expected that to happen! Yes, heavy, dripping sarcasm is intended here. With focus and belief in herself along with the support of her friend and a few misses, Isabella in the final battle with them shatters the stone by sending an electrical-like charge (the only thing she can do) at it.
After everyone is returned to their proper side of the veil, Max apologizes to Jay and Katie and the other three all become cordial with each other. Who doesn’t love a happy ending where everything turns out even better! My eyes rolled so hard when reading these little “heart-felt” scenes. Then there’s the Afterword and there I cannot beg enough, do not make a third book!
Sure we all wanted a sequel, but we wanted a sequel that didn’t follow nearly exactly like the previous story, nor did we want random musicals, not to mention all of the nods to previous Disney stories…we get it! Seriously every costume described on any NPC in the book was some Disney character. Even things the kids would say from time to time were nods to Disney like the character Travis says “Do or do not, there is no try.” Yes the character is a nerd, and yes they can use all of this without paying royalties, but essentially it is shoved in the readers’ face that this is a Disney story, and we do not need to be reminded of that, it takes us away from the story.
Technically speaking the book is mostly sound; it would earn at least a B-, maybe a basic B. As for this being a sequel, however, it is a 1-star rating. Supposedly Disney is set to make a sequel film, so let us hope that the screenwriters improve this story before Disney creates an epic flop.














